Cross posted from SkyIslandScriber.com
There were few surprises yesterday on the Senate floor as the senators delivered speeches about why they did or did not favor the confirmation of Judge Brett Kavanaugh to the US Supreme Court. The notable actions were from the supposedly undecided senators who announced how they will vote: Collins (yes), Flake (yes), Heitkamp (no), Manchin (yes), Murkowsky (no).
Susan Collins (R, Maine) took the podium at noon yesterday to defend her decision. I watched the full, hour-long presentation. I won’t (can’t, really) trouble you with her detailed defense of Kavanaugh’s judicial record, her condemnation of the confirmation process, her indictment of Kavanaugh’s opponents, her casting of doubt on Ford’s naming of Kavanaugh as Ford’s abuser. It was a bit hard not to be impressed with her defense of the presumption of innocence. However, what really grabbed me was what she did not say.
She did not talk about the dozens of potential witnesses ignored by the FBI in the reopened background check.
She did not talk about the apparent interference by the White House with that investigation.
She did not talk about the 90% of the Kavanaugh documents that were withheld from the Senators.
She did not reference the now over 2400 law professors who were united in their condemnation of the horrific rant by Kavanaugh.
She did not reference an additional letter signed by 900 female law professors.
She did not reference the announced opposition by former Supreme Court Justice John Paul Stevens.
She did not cite the American Bar Association’s concerns about Kavanaugh.
She did not mention the (rare) opposing announcement by the National Council of Churches.
She did not cite the studied editorial positions of America’s two major newspapers, the New York Times and the Washington Post.
She did not refer to the dishonesties attributed to Kavanaugh’s previous appearances before the Senate.
She did not take note of Kavanaugh’s deranged rant in which he blamed Democrats and the Clintons for the opposition to his confirmation. He stopped just short of “Lock her up!”
And, particularly galling to me: after citing the over 90% concurrence between voting patterns of Kavanaugh and Merrick Garland, she did not admit to how the Senate Republicans denied a chance for the nominee of a sitting president to be heard let alone voted upon for over a year. In ignoring McConnell’s role in that cheat, as one columnist called it, she let stand the underlying hypocrisy of this rushed Republican circus.
You can read about the details in the post this morning by the AZ Blue Meanie at Blog for Arizona who wrote Despite massive opposition, Republicans are set to confirm the most unpopular judicial nominee in American history.
David Fitzsimmons, editorial cartoonist and columnist at the Daily Star, will have the last words for now as he says I believe Christine Blasey Ford and Brett Kavanaugh told the truth.
If you are a woman, on the way to getting even, you should be seriously mad. Because, Fitz says, you know that “if a woman acted like Kavanaugh did, she would have been dismissed as a hysterical, raging bitch. If a black man acted like Kavanaugh, he would have been cuffed and searched. Any Latino who dared to act like Kavanaugh would have been put on a plane to Mexico yesterday.”
“It’s good be a preppy, Brett”, observes Fitz.
And there is one more thing Collins did not say. That’s the indelible memory that Christine Ford will carry to the grave, the memory of two drunk preppies having a laugh at her expense. Fitz again:
… the king and all the king’s men had best know that in 2018, Hell hath no fury like a woman voter scorned by her prehistoric senators. This election year, indelible in the female voter’s hippocampus as she contemplates her vote, will be the laughter. The uproarious laughter between you, Mister President, and your fans at that rally, having fun at the expense of a sexual assault victim.
If you are woman, please, please let me watch you vote.
Thanks, Bill, for this article, and thanks, Fitzsimmons, for your perspective. It makes my day a little easier to get through, knowing there are men who understand what this is about and what price needs to be paid.