Don’t Believe the Pundits, Traditional Public Education Works

Thomas photo med_2Proponents of school choice say traditional public schools are failing our children and choice is the answer.  But, open enrollment has offered school choice in Arizona since 1994 and Arizona has more charter schools than any state in the nation. Yet, Arizona is still 46th in the U.S. in education performance.  The problem isn’t parents don’t have choices.  The problem is our legislature is not focusing resources to serve the majority of our students – traditional public education.  Instead, they play a shell game to give the illusion of responsible legislation regarding education.

Take our state program of education tax credits.  The Individual Tax Credit program favors private schools with two tax credits allowed for donations to school tuition organizations for private schools totaling a maximum of $2,062 (for married filing jointly in 2013) versus $400 for traditional public schools.  The Corporate Income Tax Credit is another private school boon allowing Arizona corporations to take a dollar-for-dollar credit for donations to School Tuition Organizations (STOs), which give scholarships to private schools.

Arizona also has Empowerment Scholarship Accounts (ESAs).  Originally created for parents of disabled children, as of 2013-2014, the option will extend to:  students attending a school with a D-F letter grade, children of active duty military, and wards of the juvenile court.  ESAs allow parents to withdraw their children from public schools and receive a portion of their public funding deposited into an education savings account administered by the Arizona Department of Education and the State Treasurer. 

These special programs redistribute state revenue and help hide the truth that Arizona leads the nation in per public spending cuts since 2008 ($3 billion).  Although proponents say school choice saves the state money, this is true only if students who started out in public schools, end up in private schools.  Unfortunately, many tuition scholarships funded by the tax credits have gone to students who would have attended private schools anyway, representing a financial loss for the state.

But don’t charter schools perform better?  Yes, Tucson’s Basis High School was ranked 6th in the U.S. in 2012 by U.S. News and World report.  But, University High School of Tucson Unified School District, was ranked even higher at 4th in the U.S.  In fact, six of the top 10 high schools in Arizona and the top five high schools in the nation are traditional public schools.  There are pockets of excellence in both charter schools and traditional public schools, but by and large, they have no significant performance advantage over traditional public schools.

Charter schools and private schools serve a purpose.  But, they are not designed to serve the needs for the majority of our children.  Traditional public schools are the parental choice for almost nine out of 10 families in Arizona and these schools continue to serve these children well, despite a lack of adequate funding and support.  Just imagine what our schools could be if our efforts were properly focused and funded?


4 thoughts on “Don’t Believe the Pundits, Traditional Public Education Works

  1. When I originally commented I clicled the “Notify me when new comments are added”
    checkbox and now each time a commet is added I get three emails with the
    same comment. Is there any wway you can remove people from thatt service?

  2. My comment may sound critical, but I do appreciate your covering this issue.
    So, that being said, please explain to me how “school choice saves the state money”, which you say is true, “if students who started out in public schools, end up in private schools.” I imagine that states pay Districts a per diem amount multiplied by the number of students enrolled in their schools So, are you suggesting that the state saves an amount for each ESA student essentially equal to the overhead part of the per diem rate it would have had to pay if the student had not received the grant and chosen to take it to the private school.
    First, the state holds back 10% of what it would have paid to the District for the child — is that what is being referred to as the non labor related costs that are being saved? Not very much at all and BTW, who cares about what the state saves on the student. In most cases, the same costs being born by the District for educating a child are mostly associated with teacher salaries which will not be to be reduced if a few children receive ESA grants and bug out to private schools. As usual with cost estimates coming from State officials, the cost-comparison is made as if only a few such cases will exist each year NOT as if we were comparing making these grants to all or maybe 50% of the students and having to experience the costs of shutting down public schools and transferring teachers and students to other Public facilities.
    The point is that the District loses the per diem for each child who receives an ESA grant and they are the ones we should care about because they run and pay the bills for the schools to educate the children. The state is a bunch of losers, like, Superintendent Huppenthal, who probably would not recognize the assumptions and analyses need to go into a Cost-Benefit analysis if they bit him where the sun don’t shine.

    • Thanks for your comment. I agree with your assessment. The vast majority of funding districts get from the state come on a per-child enrolled basis. Declining enrollment caused by open enrollment or vouchers does not translate into commensurate declining overhead costs. All these “school choice” options are more about political gain versus what’s good for our students, our education system or our state.

  3. Pingback: Happy (sort of) Anniversary | Restore Reason

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s